Paid in Full - Cover

Paid in Full

by Comshaw

Copyright© 2025 by Comshaw

Erotica Sex Story: A security guard catches a young woman shoplifting and offers her a deal to avoid jail time, and so the erotica begins...

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa   Mult   Blackmail   NonConsensual   MaleDom   Humiliation   Sadistic   Anal Sex   Masturbation   Oral Sex   Petting   Size   Small Breasts   .

One Saturday I was lounging around home when the phone rang. When I answered, it was George, a friend of mine.

“Hey Bud, you busy?” George asked.

“Nope. Just watching a game on TV,” I replied.

“Remember that fifty bucks I owe you?” He said.

“Yea, you’ve owed it to me for a month. When are you going to pay it back?” I asked.

“How about right now?” George said.

“Sure,” I replied. “But why right now? Are you at work? You want to wait and bring it by later?”

“Yea, I’m at work, but I need you to come by here right away and collect it,” he said.

George works as security for a large department store, and he works most Saturdays, so it wasn’t a surprise he was working, but I was curious why he wanted me to come to his workplace right away to collect the debt he owed me.

“Why right now?” I asked.

“Trust me,” he said with laughter in his voice. “You’ll appreciate why when you get here.”

I figured what the hell, I wasn’t doing much anyway, and besides, my curiosity was getting the better of me. I drove over to the store, went inside, and found the locked door that hid the stairs leading to the upstairs office complex. I picked up the red phone next to the door and dialed George’s extension.

“Hey, I’m here,” I said as he answered my ring.

“Hang on, I’ll be right down.” He hung up, and a few minutes later, the door swung open, and George grinned at me. “Come on up!” He said.

As I followed him up the stairs, I said, “So why insist on paying me here? And now?”

He looked back at me with a grin and said, “Trust me!”

Moments later, we reached the top of the stairs. George opened a door and motioned me through. I found myself in a small room with a large window on one wall showing another small room with a table and chair.

At the table sat a young, attractive redhead. She was dressed in hip-hugging jeans, slip-on shoes, and a short, tight top that exposed much of her midriff and was tight enough to show off the firm globes of her tits. As she turned, I noticed how her breast jiggled, and looking closer, I saw the outline of her nipples through the material of her top. She didn’t have on a bra! I could feel my cock stirring as I watched her.

Finally, I tore my eyes away from the young woman and turned to George.

“Can she hear us, see us?” I asked.

“Nope. That’s a one-way glass, and the room is soundproof. She can’t see us or hear us,” he said.

“So why is she in there?” I asked, my curiosity aroused.

“I caught her,” he said, pointing at the window, “an hour ago shoplifting from the store.”

“She had on that coat,” he said, pointing to a large overcoat hung over a chair,” and she had about $3,000.00 worth of merchandise on her. That amount of money takes her out of the petty thief bracket and puts her into the grand larceny scale. That’s jail time if she’s convicted, and I have her on tape, so she is sure to be found guilty. She had some jewelry and a PDA stuffed into the pockets and several items of clothing stuffed under it.”

“So what are you going to do with her? Call the cops?” I asked.

“I’m not sure yet,” George said. “It depends on some things.”

“What things?” I asked.

“Just things,” George grinned. “But let’s get back to your payment.”

I shrugged and said, “OK. So why get me down here to pay me?”

George grinned and said, “Well, I’ve got a deal for you. I owe you $50.00, right?”

“Yeah, so?” I said, wondering what George had up his sleeve.

“So how about a trade?” He said.

“What kind of trade?” I asked.

George walked over to the window and looked at the young woman in the next room.

“Her name’s Tiffany. This is the first time she’s been caught. I talked to her for half an hour, and she told me some interesting things. Like she did it for the thrill, and her parents would kill her if they knew. She really doesn’t want this on her record, so I proposed a deal, and she accepted. But it hinges on one other thing.” He said, staring at the girl.

“What’s that?” I asked.

“She is a sexy thing, isn’t she?” George said.

“Yes, she is,” I replied, an idea of what he was going to offer in trade suddenly popping into my mind.

“The deal I offered her was sex for letting her off the hook. She’s already given me a blow job. I figured I’d offer her to you in exchange for the fifty I owe you,” George said, watching me intently.

That’s what I had suspected, but I was still a bit shocked as he voiced the offer. I stared through the window at the girl. She was attractive, and I could feel my cock stir as I thought about slipping it into her sweet, young snatch.

“Well?” George said after a few moments.

“No one is going to know about this but us?” I asked.

George grinned, knowing by my question I was going to take his offer.

“No one but the three of us, me, you, and her,” he said.

“Have you blackmailed shoplifters before?” I asked.

“Yep,” George said, a smirk stealing across his face.

“So this isn’t the first time you’ve done this. How often do you do it?” I asked.

“Every time I get a chance. About once every six months on average. Whenever I catch a young, sexy thing like Tiffany trying to shoplift.” George grinned, “Which isn’t as often as I’d like.”

As I listened to George, an idea struck me, and as he finished talking, I said, “I have an idea how we can make it happen more often. And I’ll tell you if you deal me in on a regular basis.”

George looked thoughtful and said, “How often are we talking?”

“If it works, once a week or more,” I said.

He grinned and said, “If I can get some young pussy once a week, you’re on!”

I said, “Here’s what we do...”

A few minutes later, we both walked into the room where Tiffany waited.

“Who-who are you?” She asked, looking at me.

“He’s an integral part of our deal,” George said. “He’s the one you’re going to fuck.”

The young redhead stammered, “But ... I ... you said, what I did earlier...”

George grinned and cut her off, “No buts, honey. The blow job was just an earnest payment. I told you before you were going to have to fuck for me, ignoring what you did. Well, he’s the one you’re going to do it with.”

Tiffany looked frightened but seemed to know she shouldn’t argue. She nodded her head in agreement.

George said, “Besides, we need to talk to you about another part we’ve decided to add to this deal.”

“B-but you said...” Tiffany began to protest.

“I know, but we’re going to add to it. You can try and leave now, but if you do, I’ll just call the cops,” George said. “And don’t think you can tell them about our deal and make them believe it. I have you on tape stealing, remember? I think they’ll believe me and not a thief caught in the act.”

Her shoulders slumped as she accepted the circumstances.

She let out a sigh and said, “OK.”

“As I promised, I’ll give you the surveillance tape of you shoplifting, but only after you fulfill the requirements,” George said.”First, you fuck my buddy here, and two, you tell some of your girlfriends how easy it is to shoplift from this store. Get them to try it. Of course, you will let me know who they are and when they will be here so I can catch them.

“Don’t worry, none of them will go to jail. They will be given the same deal you have: fuck or get turned over to the cops. As soon as I have the first one you send on tape, I’ll give you your tape. So what do you say? Or do you want the alternative?”

Tiffany sat for a full minute, then slowly nodded her head, “O-OK. I-I’ll do it.”

“I don’t want to do her in here,” I said. “Anybody can walk in and see us. You got a better place?”

“Follow me.” George said to me, then adding to the young redhead, “I’ll be back in a few minutes to get you.”

I followed George out of the room down a hall and into another. It appeared to be a storage room and had a desk with a couple of chairs stacked atop it, a pile of boxes against one wall, and a couch with several more boxes piled on the cushions.

“Will this do?” he asked with a grin.

“It will do,” I said, pulling the boxes off the couch and putting them on the floor.

“Wait here, and I’ll send her in,” George said. “You’ll have a couple of hours, so enjoy!”

I leaned against the desk as I waited. A few moments later, George opened the door and led the redhead into the room.

“OK, Tiff, as we discussed, fucking him is part of the deal. Go to it!” George said.

She stood, biting her lip, saying nothing.

George grinned and said as he stepped out the door, “I’ve got the only key for this room. I’ll lock the door and be back in a couple of hours unless you finish earlier. If you do, come find me.”

After he closed the door, I walked over and checked it to make sure it was locked.

I turned to Tiffany and looked her over again. She stood, staring at the floor, a scared expression on her face. She was young, 16 from what George had said, slim, and very attractive.

“Come here,” I said.

She glanced up at me, and I motioned for her to come. She walked slowly over to me and stood in front of me, staring at the floor.

“Look at me,” I said.

A few moments went by, and finally, she looked up, meeting my eyes.

“OK. We have two hours,” I said. “I’m going to get my money’s worth, so...”

I pulled her to me and cupped her young, firm breast. As I thought when I saw her through the window, she didn’t have on a bra. I could feel her erect nipple against my palm as I squeezed and kneaded her tit.

“I-I-I’m not sure I want to. I-I think I’ve changed...” She stammered, and I could feel her trying to pull away from me.

I jerked her hard against me and pinched her nipple between my fingers.

“Too bad, little girl, it’s way too late to change your mind. You’re about to get your sweet little cunt packed with cock.”

She used her hands to push against me, again trying to pull away and stammered, “I-I-I don’t want to!”

I grinned, grabbed both her wrists with my hands, pulled them behind her, and held them with one hand. I slipped my fingers under the bottom hem of her top and slowly pulled it up, relishing the sight as first I bared her stomach, then both her small, firm tits. I grinned as they popped free of her top, and I was treated to the sight of her nipples standing hard and erect.

“Please,” she whimpered, “Please, I’m not sure I want...”

I cupped one of her small, bare, firm tits, placed my lips against her ear, and whispered, “Sure, candy britches, I’ll stop. But if I do, you go to jail. So this is your last chance, choose, jail or getting stuffed with a hard cock.”

We stood there for moments, me rubbing her tit, rolling her nipple between my fingers as it grew harder and more erect. When she didn’t answer, I slid my hand from her tit slowly down over her stomach until my fingers touched the button of her jeans. With one flip of my fingers, I had it unbuttoned. I grasped the zipper and slowly pulled it down. When it hit the bottom, I slipped my fingers into the top of her panties until I could feel her curly pubes and a moment later the silky feel of the inside of her cunt as my finger slipped between the warm lips of her snatch.

“Choose now,” I said, “Jail or my cock.”

“I-I-I...” She stammered.

“Choose, NOW!” I growled as my finger slid up and down along the lips of her cunt.

“Please, I-I-I...” She again stammered.

“OK,” I said, letting go of her wrists and pulling my hand out of her panties, “I’ll go get George, and he can call the cops.”

“NO, PLEASE DON’T!” She gasped in panic.

I grinned, grabbed her, and began to work her jeans down off her hips, “You don’t want me to call George, then you must agree to the other.”

“No, I ... but...” She again started to protest.

I jerked her to me, grabbed a handful of hair, and pulled her head back so she was looking up at me.

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is HotSexStories

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

HotSexStories is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In