Be Careful What You Wish For
Copyright© 2025 by John D. Rodburn
Chapter 2
Incest Sex Story: Chapter 2 - He wished he would be caught between all the girls in his sister's sleepover, well...
Caution: This Incest Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Mult Consensual Fiction Incest Brother Sister Pregnancy
I guess they couldn’t figure out any more that Kara could do with me, until it was Sonya’s turn. She picked Kara again. Kara picked “dare”.
“I’m assuming that you’re not afraid to do anything with Chad, so I have a dare for you that I think he’ll like.” She looked around at the other girls, at me, then back at Kara. “Slide your hand down the front of Chad’s pants, then slide it up and down a few times.”
Kara didn’t flinch. She stood behind me, reached her hand around me, then slid it down the front of my pants. Her fingers formed around my dick as she did.
“Just a few times?” she asked in a whisper.
“No,” I said, as I slightly shook my head.
As she slid her hand in, the zipper went all the way down. She started sliding her hand, and I thought I was going to lose it. She kept it up for the allotted minute, but kept going.
“Ok, Kara,” Sonya said. “Time is up.”
“For who? This is what you really want me to do, isn’t it? How about if I pull it out and do it?”
“That isn’t...”
Kara pushed my pants down a little, then pulled my dick straight out in front of them. She started using her whole hand then.
“Any arguments?” she asked. Nobody moved.
It was bad enough that she was doing what she was doing. She also had her legs straddling mine, her mound against my hip, and her other hand all over my ass. She even had her tits pressed into my side. That is, until she sensed that I was going to make a mess.
She looked up at me just as it was going up the tube, then bent down and didn’t miss a drop. She kept sliding her hand up and down until I was done, then pulled her mouth off of it. I looked up then, and saw quite a few hands inside of those panties and bras. One of them was Gwen.
I think one girl did have a climax, but they all pulled their hands free when they saw me looking at them. Kara got real close to Gwen, said something, then Gwen smiled. Kara stepped back. I didn’t bother pulling my pants up, and no one asked me to.
“It’s my turn,” Kara said.
“I think ... we’ve gone far enough,” Sonya said.
“For whom? The night is still young. Does anyone else want to quit?” Nobody said a word. “Ok. Gwen. Truth or dare.”
“Dare,” she said, almost in a whisper.
“Take off as much as you want to in front of my brother, then rub your tits all over his chest.”
Gwen didn’t miss a beat. She pulled off her bra, then dropped her panties. She stepped right up to me, then began rubbing her tits on my chest. I wrapped my arms around her, then slid my hands down her back.
“Another dream has just come true,” I told her.
“For me too,” she said, as she looked up at me. She pushed her mound into my dick right then. “If that’s all I can do to that, I’ll be happy.”
“Keep playing your cards right, Gwen.”
She backed off, but kept one arm around my waist. My pants chose that moment to drop to the floor. I stepped out of them, and kicked them aside. I kept one arm around her too, but kept sliding my hand down until it was on her ass.
The game went on. By the time it was over, every girl in there was naked. By then, too, it was getting late, and everyone was getting tired. They did play one more round, though. It was Gwen’s turn to pick someone. She chose Kara, and Kara chose “truth”.
“I know what’s on all of our minds tonight. Given that we’re all thinking about sex, would you have sex with your brother?”
“Yes,” she said, with no hesitation. She smiled at me. Everyone was awake then.
As luck would have it, it came around to Kara again.
“With Chad lying on the floor, rub his dick on your clit until you cum.”
My sister didn’t wait for that final word. She had a spot picked out, and made sure I got in it. She straddled my legs, grabbed my dick, then started stroking it on herself. At one point, she got so excited that she got up on her knees. My dick was right under her then.